AbeBooks' Reading Copy

AbeBooks book blog

Advanced Search Browse Books Rare Books Textbooks
Advanced Search

Jamrach’s Menagerie by Carol Birch – Design Deja Vu


Just an observation while reading about the runners-up for the 2011 Booker Prize (congratulations Julian Barnes) – is it just me, or does the paperback version of Carol Birch’s book Jamrach’s Menagerie bear an uncanny resemblance to David Mitchell’s Cloud Atlas?

I suppose there are trends in cover design and only so many combinations of colors and layouts and shapes etcetera – but these do seem awfully close, to me. Anybody else notice that?

Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email
Beth Carswell

About Beth Carswell

I've been reading, selling, researching, loving and writing about books with AbeBooks since 2000.

3 Responses to “Jamrach’s Menagerie by Carol Birch – Design Deja Vu”

  1. Well I know that she had to change the cover because WH Smith asked her too. Also, we just wrote a song about the book when Carol came into our local bookshop. If anyone fancies having a listen, in some way it will give you a taster for the book. http://vimeo.com/30924451

  2. Weird, I actually googled this because I saw the book on the shelves at my local bookstore and immediately snatched it up to see if I could find the design information, because it looks EXACTLY like the cover of Jessica Au’s Cargo.

    http://www.killyourdarlingsjournal.com/2011/10/story-of-a-cover-cargo/#more-4160

    That being said I know nothing about design and copyright or any of that stuff and haven’t been able to find out yet from my brief googling frenzy who designed Jamrach’s Menagerie – for all I know it’s the same person or a regular practise in the book industry! Or they just had similar inspirations. But yeah, I think we can confirm that Cloud Atlas + Cargo = Jamrach’s Menagerie?

  3. Yes! I noticed exactly this – with pique, being a big fan of David Mitchell’s work and anything closely associated!

    But that’s book design for you: I work at Waterstone’s and if you look at (what were) the 3for2 tables, which is a pretty good cross-section of recently published mainstream fiction, you can group into just 3 or 4 categories the design concepts being used. I can’t imagine the designer of Cloud Atlas would be terribly bothered. It’s the nature of commercial (or any) art, isn’t it?

    I still think the David Mitchell cover is the better design. The other’s not bad work but the first book has the better use of typefaces.