Posts Tagged ‘Holocaust’

Doorstepping the Rosenblats

Monday, February 16th, 2009

The Observer doorsteps Herman and Roma Rosenblat of Angel at the Fence made-up memoir infamy.

It’s a strange article all around. This fuss blew up just before Christmas so The Observer isn’t exactly quick off the mark here. Also if you are going to doorstep someone when you many as well do it properly, hang around for a few days and make them answer some questions.

When I ring their bell, Roma answers, her unsmiling face blurred by the mesh of the security screen. She is a squat but formidable 76-year-old, wearing a striped shirt over cream trousers and lumpish slippers. Her short hair is dyed brown. Her small, dark eyes squint into the light. Herman, 78, is standing silently in the corridor behind her, an imposing man in glasses and a goatee.

I ask if they are Mr and Mrs Rosenblat. “No,” she says flatly, in a thick eastern European accent. “They’re not here. They don’t live here.” But having already seen photos of the couple, I know it is them. When I say I would like to give them a letter, it is Herman who softens. He takes a few steps forward and gestures with his hands for Roma to open the screen. She takes the letter and closes the door. As I walk away, I wonder if either of them is struck by the irony that they are still lying about who they are.

Angel at the Fence – another fabricated memoir?

Wednesday, December 24th, 2008

Angel at the FenceIs 2008 going to end with a revelation about another made-up memoir? Perhaps. The book in question is Angel at the Fence: The True Story of a Love That Survived by Herman Rosenblat, who has twice appeared on Oprah’s TV show. The book is set to be published by a division of Penguin in February and a movie called Flower of the Fence is scheduled to go into production in 2009.

The author describes his experience as a teenage boy during the Holocaust at Schlieben, part of the Buchenwald concentration camp. One day a nine-year-old girl appears and throws an apple over the fence to Herman and continues to bring food for months, helping Herman to survive. After the war, Herman moves to New York and meet a Polish immigrant named Roma Radzicki, who turns out to be that same girl and they fall in love and marry.

However, the New Republic reveals the facts don’t add up and Herman’s description of the camp is inaccurate – and that throwing an apple over the camp’s fence would be impossible.

James Frey, Ishmael Beah, Margaret B Jones, Misha Defonseca – the list of authors accused of fabrication goes on and on. Is Herman Rosenblat the latest one? It will be interesting to see where this story goes.

It could be another very embarrassing episode for Oprah – the memories of James Frey’s Oprah misadventure remain as clear as a bell.