Doubt: A History: The Great Doubters and Their Legacy of Innovation from Socrates and Jesus to Thomas Jefferson and Emily Dickinson – An Intellectual History of Western Skepticism - Softcover

Jennifer Michael Hecht

Softcover

ISBN 10: 0060097957 ISBN 13: 9780060097950

Publisher: HarperOne, 2004

Synopsis

In the tradition of grand sweeping histories such as From Dawn To Decadence, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, and A History of God, Hecht champions doubt and questioning as one of the great and noble, if unheralded, intellectual traditions that distinguish the Western mind especially-from Socrates to Galileo and Darwin to Wittgenstein and Hawking. This is an account of the world's greatest ‘intellectual virtuosos,' who are also humanity's greatest doubters and disbelievers, from the ancient Greek philosophers, Jesus, and the Eastern religions, to modern secular equivalents Marx, Freud and Darwin—and their attempts to reconcile the seeming meaninglessness of the universe with the human need for meaning,

This remarkable book ranges from the early Greeks, Hebrew figures such as Job and Ecclesiastes, Eastern critical wisdom, Roman stoicism, Jesus as a man of doubt, Gnosticism and Christian mystics, medieval Islamic, Jewish and Christian skeptics, secularism, the rise of science, modern and contemporary critical thinkers such as Schopenhauer, Darwin, Marx, Freud, Nietzsche, the existentialists.

About this title

About the Author

Jennifer Michael Hecht is a philosopher, historian, and award-winning poet. She is the author of Doubt: A History and The End of the Soul; the latter won the Phi Beta Kappa Society's 2004 Ralph Waldo Emerson Award. Hecht's books of poetry include The Next Ancient World and Funny. She earned her Ph.D. in history from Columbia University and teaches at The New School in New York City.

From the Back Cover

In the tradition of grand sweeping histories such as From Dawn To Decadence, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, and A History of God, Hecht champions doubt and questioning as one of the great and noble, if unheralded, intellectual traditions that distinguish the Western mind especially-from Socrates to Galileo and Darwin to Wittgenstein and Hawking. This is an account of the world's greatest ‘intellectual virtuosos,' who are also humanity's greatest doubters and disbelievers, from the ancient Greek philosophers, Jesus, and the Eastern religions, to modern secular equivalents Marx, Freud and Darwin—and their attempts to reconcile the seeming meaninglessness of the universe with the human need for meaning,

This remarkable book ranges from the early Greeks, Hebrew figures such as Job and Ecclesiastes, Eastern critical wisdom, Roman stoicism, Jesus as a man of doubt, Gnosticism and Christian mystics, medieval Islamic, Jewish and Christian skeptics, secularism, the rise of science, modern and contemporary critical thinkers such as Schopenhauer, Darwin, Marx, Freud, Nietzsche, the existentialists.

Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.

Doubt

A History: The Great Doubters and Their Legacy of Innovation from Socrates and Jesus to Thomas Jefferson and Emily DickinsonBy Hecht, Jennifer Michael

HarperSanFrancisco

ISBN: 0060097957

Chapter One

Whatever Happened
to Zeus and Hera?,

600 BCE -- 1 CE

Greek Doubt

When we look for doubt among the ancients, in the West we are goingto find the most lively cases in the Hellenistic period -- the few hundredyears between the dominance of Classical Greece and that of ClassicalRome.It's not surprising that an in-between period is our main focus:human beings define which are the pinnacle moments of history and whichare the in-between moments, and we tend to choose moments of certainty aspinnacles. We praise and envy the certainty, dedication, and meaningfulnessof such moments, whether we look at ancient Greece or at a small town inearly America. In our modern lives, many of us actively cultivate our differencesfrom these unified communities, in defense of privacy and autonomy.Yet we tend to laud them and long for them, because the ideal members ofthese societies seem to have been so well nourished by them; intellectuallyand emotionally, they do not seem bereft. We moderns can't cotton to theconstraints and gross inequalities?ideal membership is usually limited, havingto do with gender, heredity, and/or wealth -- but we marvel at the generalideas of the group, at the rich and jubilant belonging, and at the ideal members'noble and satisfying engagement in civic affairs. Our quickest shorthandfor the past is a list of these highly principled moments, their breakdown, andthe birth of the next. So the history of doubt looks different than other histories,because it highlights what goes on between periods of certainty: it's like seeing a map upside down -- it takes time for the new contours to take shape.The history of being awake to certain contradictions of our condition is thenegative image of the history of certainty.

Hence, while usual histories of the ancient world would linger on thecertainty of Classical Greece and then rush through its dissolution over thenext few hundred years, I will briefly discuss Greek piety and then linger onthe budding of doubt at the end of the Classical age and its blooming in theHellenistic period that followed.

In the heyday of the ancient Greek polis, or city-state, the gods over-sawa very well integrated society. Although every society has some senseof itself as old, as having seen a lot, this was a society with a primary relationshipto its religious ideas, and the strength of each of the many poleishad a lot to do with this primary certainty, this lack of doubt. Ideally, youlived for the polis, you worshiped its particular gods, you knew most fellowmembers by face, and you took part in its governance and defense. Itwas the central object of identity, politics, and religion. It was an identitythat was bigger than the self and bigger than the family. It was oftenuncomfortable for people to subordinate themselves thusly, but they wereextraordinarily well nurtured in doing so.

The polis assuaged confusion and doubt because it was something midwaybetween the world of humanness and the universe at large, and couldserve as a shelter. If humanity's central existential difficulty comes from thefact that we have humanness -- consciousness, hopes, dreams, loneliness,shame, plans, memory, a sense of fairness, love -- and the universe does not,that means that we are constantly trying to wrangle our needs out of a universethat does not tend in such directions. The polis expanded humannessso it seemed longer-lived and larger. The aim of each person's life is to do hisor her part in the polis, to serve in a given capacity, to worship the gods ofthe polis, to fight, to procreate, to keep the thing going.

The Olympian gods were not very remote from humanity. They hadn'tcreated human beings. They were immortal but not eternal. They wereoften heroic, but they were not particularly honorable in their dealings withone another or with human beings. They were imminent in human life andin the environment: they brought meaningful dreams to sleepers and threwthunderbolts when they were angry. They even lived nearby, on MountOlympus. They also gave an external cause for human inconsistency orillogic, such as the mystery of why certain people find each other attractiveand lovable -- as if struck by an arrow. Along with the gods, there were the even more immediate daemons, vaguely drawn embodiments of occult power.Sometimes they were doing a god's bidding; at other times they weredescribed as the enacting force of the moment, animating someone to heroism,great speed, or tragic error.

At the height of their cult, the Olympic gods of the Greeks werethought of as very real -- not at all the equivalent of parables or half-believedfairy tales. The sun did rise every day, it was indeed the source of all life, itwas perfectly consistent in its behavior, and its rising and setting was avision of spectacular beauty. If we call immense, nonhuman power gods orGod, then it is purely descriptive to say that the god Apollo drives his chariotacross the sky every day, and perfectly appropriate to express awe at thesight of it. It may be a bit less obvious that Eros is a purely descriptive per-sonificationof erotic love, because we don't believe that erotic love exists asa thing outside of human beings. Yet passion can seem to hit us from theoutside, and that's how the Greeks saw it.

The great authorities of the culture were Homer and Hesiod, poets whohad crafted wonderful praise poems detailing the historical adventures ofthe gods. In these stories, people were driven in and out of wars, friendships,and adventures because of the whims or ardent desires of gods.Everyone knew these stories, and for centuries upon centuries the lives ofordinary Greeks were interpreted within this engaging and satisfying, if alsodisturbing, context ...

Continues...

Excerpted from Doubtby Hecht, Jennifer Michael Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Edition details

• Publisher: HarperOne
• Publication date: 2004
• Language: English
• ISBN 10: 0060097957
• ISBN 13: 9780060097950
• Binding: Paperback
• Number of pages: 576