Renegotiating Health Care: Resolving Conflict to Build Collaboration (Cloth Edition) (JOSSEY BASS/AHA PRESS SERIES) - Hardcover

Marcus, Leonard J.; Dorn, Barry C.; Kritek, Phyllis Beck; Miller, Velvet G.; Wyatt, Janice B.

Hardcover

ISBN 10: 0787901512 ISBN 13: 9780787901516

Publisher: Jossey-Bass, 1995

Synopsis

Renegotiating Health Care is a practical guide to collaboration written at a time of extensive change for the system. It presents effective tools for understanding conflict, negotiating differences, and creating a workable balance among those who deliver, receive, administer, and oversee health care.

About this title

Review:

Q&A with the Authors of Renegotiating Health Care: Resolving Conflict to Build Collaboration

What do you mean by “renegotiating” health care?

For many decades, health care was a relatively predictable experience for patients, doctors, nurses, administrators, insurers, and policy makers. For the past 20 years it has been changing more rapidly and more radically – and the intensity change is increasing. The push to lower costs and improve quality, the shortage of doctors and nurses, and the increasing sophistication of patients are among the trends calling much in the system that we’ve taken for granted into question. With that comes the potential both for conflit and collaboration – every stakeholder in the system will benefit from knowing how to negotiate and resolve conflict constructively.

What are some of those major trends and what are the implications?

One of the most significant is the expanding use of technology. Technology has long been important in delivering treatment; it is becoming much more important in managing the system. For example, there is a growing move to make evidence-driven treatment protocols the default option for many conditions. Doctors are used to exercising their own discretion in choosing what is best for their patients and some resist the loss of control. Patients now have ready access to many digital resources that allow them to look clinical studies, converse with other patients, and peruse performance and cost data. Administrators and insurers have ever-more detailed information on utilization rates, revenue and cost flows, and outcomes. Each of these shifts the power balance in the system and can cause conflict.

Other trends are the aging of population and increased diversity in the workforce. If people have the tools to navigate these changes in a positive way, the system can function more productively. If not, everyone will feel the pain.

What is distinct about your approach to negotiation and conflict resolution?

We have been teaching negotiation and conflict resolution to students, through our work at the Harvard School of Public Health, and to professionals in a consulting role for more than two decades. Over that time we have developed a series of practical, proven concepts and tools that can be used in everyday situations in healthcare. For too many people, their negotiation “training” has come in the context of buying a car or a house – a unidimensional, often confrontational setting. The issues one finds in healthcare are typically multidimensional and confrontational negotiation doesn’t solve the problem. It often compounds it. We have found that when people have a process for multi-dimensional problem solving that they can understand and readily deploy, they approach conflict and negotiation with a different, more hopeful mindset. They seek win-win outcomes rather than trying to “beat” the other party.

One of tools we offer in the book is called “The Walk in the Woods.” It is a four-step process for reframing conflict so that new possibilities – distinct from what either party started the negotiation thinking of as a “win” – can emerge through collaboration. It can be used in a 20-minute performance review or a major policy debate. In fact, we wish Congress and the President had used it when they were debating health care reform. The process might have been less acrimonious and the parties would not have ended the process with such bitterness about the outcome.

In the book you write about leadership. How is this connected to negotiation and conflict resolution?

Many of the people who read this book will be leaders or would-be leaders in some part of the health care system. We believe that negotiation is a critical leadership skill. One hospital CEO we interviewed for the book noted that every interaction between two or more people for which there is a desired outcome is, in effect, a negotiation. Leaders have many, many such interactions each and every day. They have to be able to negotiate and resolve conflict if they are to be effective.

We present a framework we call meta-leadership that is based on observing leaders in high stress, high stakes situations – many when lives were at stake. It addresses the challenges not only of leading one’s subordinates, the focus of most leadership models, but also in leading up to one’s boss and across to one’s peers and external stakeholders such as regulators and communities. It is a 360-degree approach to leadership that we feel reflects the reality that many in health care face.

From the Inside Flap:

For all who work in health care, the daily routine requires constant negotiation of conflict. Decisions affecting numerous people must be made. Competing priorities have to be balanced. And there is constant pressure that the job be done correctly, often within strict time limits. This book offers a practical guide to help better understand conflict, negotiate choices, and build systems to improve the processes of decision making. Renegotiating Healthcare takes successful negotiation and conflict resolution concepts developed over the past ten years and sets them in current day health care settings. Through narrative, example, and theory, the book gives all the players in health care—physicians, hospital management, nurses, and public health and public policy leaders—the knowledge and skills they need to put things in perspective and work out problems in an arena where issues, authority, and responsibility are still unclear.

"The health care sphere we inhabit would unquestionably be more satisfying if everyone adopted the cooperative techniques taught in this book."
—New England Journal of Medicine

Renegotiating Health Care presents pragmatic and effective tools for understanding conflict, negotiating differences, and creating a workable balance among those who deliver, receive, administer, and oversee health care. The authors present practical methods and techniques giving all the players the knowledge and skills they need to put their work in perspective and create workable solutions.

"Renegotiating Health Care highlights key skills of public health practice. It is an excellent book for those who aspire to leadership."
—Deborah Prothrow-Stith, M.D., associate dean, Harvard School of Public Health

About this edition

• Publisher: Jossey-Bass
• Publication date: 1995
• ISBN 10: 0787901512
• ISBN 13: 9780787901516
• Binding: Hardcover
• Edition number: 1
• Number of pages: 453