"synopsis" may belong to another edition of this title.
Despite its general merits, A Time to Die suffers from several weaknesses. A theoretical question underlying the debate is the ethical distinction between, or equivalence of, physician-assisted death and the legally established, standard practice of forgoing life-sustaining treatment. McKhann effectively rebuts the traditional argument for a moral distinction: that it is the disease that causes death when life-sustaining treatment is withdrawn, whereas in physician-assisted suicide it is the provision of lethal medication that causes death and that terminating life is the intent of physician-assisted death but not typically of the withdrawal of treatment. Yet McKhann does not discuss the position that refusal of treatment, but not assisted death, is grounded in the basic right of persons to be free of unwanted bodily intrusion. According to that perspective, when a competent patient refuses life-sustaining treatment, physicians are morally obligated to comply. In contrast, competent, terminally ill patients are not owed assistance toward death as a right, though it may be the best option for patients facing intolerable suffering.
Within the penumbra of the patient's right to refuse medical treatment is the right to hasten death by voluntarily stopping eating and drinking. McKhann mentions but does not give due attention to this important alternative to physician-assisted death. This legally permitted option may seem less humane than the swift means of ingesting or injecting lethal medication; however, anecdotal evidence suggests that a peaceful death can be achieved by refusing food and water, provided that the patient receives standard palliative and supportive care. The time required to bring about death by ceasing to eat and drink, typically from a few days to a few weeks, should be compared with a mandatory two-week waiting period following a request for lethal medication -- a feature of the law in Oregon legalizing physician-assisted suicide and similar legislative proposals elsewhere. This alternative arguably displays greater evidence of the self-determination of patients and poses less threat to the professional integrity of physicians.
The weakest chapter of the book addresses the concern that legalizing physician-assisted death would invite intolerable abuse. McKhann appears confident that physicians empowered to assist patients in dying will engage in this practice responsibly. For example, he argues that "if withdrawing treatment is not considered to be an easy way out, assisted dying is even less likely to be." This may be true for euthanasia by lethal injection. But prescribing lethal medication at the request of a terminally ill patient, and not knowing whether the patient will actually use the drugs to cause death, may be a tempting "quick fix," obviating the demanding work of caring for the dying. Moreover, McKhann's position that physician-assisted death, authorized by patients' advance directives, should be available to patients with severe dementia is fraught with peril. It remains an open question whether safeguards such as mandatory consultation by an independent physician would provide adequate protection of vulnerable patients. In view of realistic concern about the potential for abuse, there is reason to doubt McKhann's prediction that the legalization of physician-assisted death, beyond the Oregon referendum, is inevitable.
Reviewed by Franklin G. Miller, Ph.D.
Copyright © 1998 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved. The New England Journal of Medicine is a registered trademark of the MMS.
"About this title" may belong to another edition of this title.
Shipping:
FREE
Within U.S.A.
Book Description PAP. Condition: New. New Book. Shipped from UK. THIS BOOK IS PRINTED ON DEMAND. Established seller since 2000. Seller Inventory # L0-9780300086980
Book Description Condition: New. pp. 284. Seller Inventory # 263856748
Book Description Paperback. Condition: New. Brand New. 100% Money Back Guarantee! Ships within 1 business day, includes tracking. Carefully packed. Successful business for 25 Years!. Seller Inventory # 124132
Book Description Condition: New. pp. 284 401:B&W 5.5 x 8.5 in or 216 x 140 mm (Demy 8vo) Perfect Bound on Creme w/Matte Lam. Seller Inventory # 5072563
Book Description Condition: New. PRINT ON DEMAND Book; New; Fast Shipping from the UK. No. book. Seller Inventory # ria9780300086980_lsuk
Book Description Condition: New. Seller Inventory # ABLIING23Feb2215580096345
Book Description Paperback / softback. Condition: New. This item is printed on demand. New copy - Usually dispatched within 5-9 working days. Seller Inventory # C9780300086980
Book Description PF. Condition: New. Seller Inventory # 6666-IUK-9780300086980
Book Description PAP. Condition: New. New Book. Delivered from our UK warehouse in 4 to 14 business days. THIS BOOK IS PRINTED ON DEMAND. Established seller since 2000. Seller Inventory # L0-9780300086980
Book Description Condition: New. An examination of the dying process as it is experienced in painful and debilitating diseases from the point of view of the sufferers and their families. The author considers the idea of assisted suicides, and also reflects on religious, moral and legal iss. Seller Inventory # 594503332