By Their Deeds Alone: America's Combat Commanders on the Art of War - Softcover

9780891418078: By Their Deeds Alone: America's Combat Commanders on the Art of War
View all copies of this ISBN edition:
 
 
· Lt. Col. Robert R. Leonhard, “Soldiers of Gideon: The Defense of the Golan, Oct. 1973”–how Israel bested a Syrian onslaught, typified by the effort of Lt. Zvi “Zwicka” Greengold, who convinced his adversaries they were up against a force of tanks, when he was armed with only one.

From the Battle of Gallipoli in 1915 to the Allied chase of German forces across France in 1944 to the crippling of the Russian Army by Chechen rebels in 1995, battlefield fights and fireworks throughout the century are recounted in brilliant detail, revealing all the action–and wisdom–they have to offer, in powerful prose by military professionals.
“Leadership, not machines, not doctrine, not even logistics, is the supreme element in war.” These are the words of Lt. Col. Richard Hooker, editor of By Their Deeds Alone. They describe the lesson taught by this extraordinary collection, a gripping and inspiring anthology of battle histories written by brave men who’ve been there themselves. Here are dramatic retellings and relevant interpretations of campaigns recent and remote, famous and forgotten–designed to teach tactics to today’s military leaders as well as inform and entertain any history or military buff.

Ten accomplished historians–at once combat commanders and acclaimed authors–transport you to the front lines of real battles in wars from around the world, including:

· Col. John Antal, “A Most Daring Enterprise: The Conquest of Fortress Singapore”–in a cautionary tale for any country facing a “weaker” foe, the Imperial Japanese Army defeats a superior force of overconfident British–and conquers the supposedly impregnable fortress of Singapore

· Col. James R. McDonough, “African Holocaust: The Rwandan Civil War”–in 1994, quiet and introverted master of infiltration Paul Kagame took the nation’s capital, Kigali, with his Rwandan Patriotic Front, defeating a foreign-funded government force.

· Lt. Col. Robert R. Leonhard, “Soldiers of Gideon: The Defense of the Golan, Oct. 1973”–how Israel bested a Syrian onslaught, typified by the effort of Lt. Zvi “Zwicka” Greengold, who convinced his adversaries they were up against a force of tanks, when he was armed with only one.

From the Battle of Gallipoli in 1915 to the Allied chase of German forces across France in 1944 to the crippling of the Russian Army by Chechen rebels in 1995, battlefield fights and fireworks throughout the century are recounted in brilliant detail, revealing all the action–and wisdom–they have to offer, in powerful prose by military professionals.

"synopsis" may belong to another edition of this title.

Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.:
Michael R. Fenzel

“I Order You to Die”: Kemal at Gallipoli

How many armies have sworn to conquer or perish? How many have kept their oath? —Ardant du Picq

On 25 April 1915, Allied forces began to land on the narrow beaches below Gaba Tepe on the Gallipoli peninsula, not far from the fabled Plains of Troy. From the high ground of Sari Bair above, a small band of Turkish infantry watched in terror, mesmerized at the sight of the British fleet disgorging its cargo. As the first Australian patrols approached, the peasant soldiers defending the heights began to stream to the rear. At that moment, a lean-faced, mustachioed Turkish colonel galloped up, his face a mask of utter disdain. “Where are you going?” he shouted. “Fix your bayonets and face the enemy!” The soldiers of the Turkish 19th Infantry Division obeyed instantly, for they knew their fiery commander well. Though unknown to the outside world, he would rise to greatness as the savior and father of the modern Turkish state. His name was Mustafa Kemal.

In the summer of 1915 the Allies—France, Britain, and Russia—faced stalemate and possible defeat on the continent of Europe at the hands of Germany and Austria. The nightmare of trench warfare had already settled over the battlefield in the west, while in the east the Russians had suffered catastrophes at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes. Seeking to break the stalemate, British First Lord of the Admiralty Winston Churchill suggested Gallipoli as a likely place to strike back with British sea power.

The Gallipoli peninsula, located on the northeastern corner of the Aegean Sea, controlled the approaches to the Dardanelles Straits, Constantinople, and ultimately the Black Sea. For the Allies, control of the Dardanelles would open a sea-lane to key ports in Russia and, it was hoped, help encircle Germany. With Churchill its passionate advocate, the Gallipoli operation was given the grudging support of Lord Horatio Kitchener, the British war minister, who was always reluctant to draw forces away from the main theater of war. At first the British, with French support, attempted to force the Na on the Asiatic side with naval forces alone. When that failed with the loss of four warships, the Allies planned an amphibious assault to take the barren peninsula.

General Sir Ian Hamilton, a Kitchener protégé and veteran of the Boer War, commanded the Allied effort. Experienced, highly intellectual, and gentlemanly to a fault, the sixty-two-year-old Hamilton was known throughout the British army as a brilliant soldier and must have seemed an inspired choice. Hamilton’s forces initially totaled some 80,000 troops and 118 guns, supported by powerful naval forces. The ground force consisted of two divisions of untested Australians and New Zealanders (30,000 men) under Lt. Gen. Sir William Birdwood, the regular army 29th Division (19,000 men) commanded by Lt. Gen. Sir Aylmer Hunter-Weston, the Royal Naval Division (11,000 men) led by Major General Paris, a French contingent of roughly division size commanded by General d’Amade, and service troops.

Hamilton’s opposite number was Generalleutnant Limon von Sanders, a distinguished German officer of strong leadership qualities and stable temperament. Sanders was a man of impressive authority with the trained habit of command. At Gallipoli he commanded the Ottoman Fifth Army, six divisions strong, drawn from all over the Ottoman Empire and stiffened by German staff officers and commanders. Two divisions protected the Asiatic shore, buttressed by German gunners under a German admiral. Another two guarded the Bulair lines to the north at the neck of the Gallipoli peninsula. One was stationed at Cape Helles, at the southern tip. The last was Kemal’s division, posted in the center of the peninsula on the high ground running across its spine, ready to move wherever the Allies gained a foothold. Watching von Sanders and his frighteningly efficient staff officers, members of the young Turkish officer corps, who had taken over the ailing government, were convinced that “it was not these generals who would lose.”

Mustafa Kemal was a study in contrasts. Brooding, driven, passionate, the young lieutenant colonel had just returned from Salonika. Trained at a formal military school in Turkey, his life’s desire was to achieve military success and then use it as a springboard to political power. No dilettante, Kemal had served in the 1909 officer’s mutiny and in campaigns in Albania, Tripolitania, and the Balkans—all of which enhanced his reputation in military circles. A difficult subordinate who was proud, willful, and obstinate, Kemal possessed genuine military talent and was not afraid of responsibility. To his credit, von Sanders recognized these gifts and overlooked Kemal’s abrasive personality.

Recalled from unimportant duties in the backwaters of the empire, Kemal had commanded in the area years before and was familiar with the unforgiving terrain and craggy cliffs that sliced into the Aegean. He wasted no time in readying his forces. The rumor spreading through Constantinople was that the Allies were going to attempt to breach the Dardanelles with a naval force. Pushing his men relentlessly, Kemal prepared them and himself for the ordeal that lay ahead.

General Ian Hamilton, though personally selected by Lord Kitchener to command the expedition, was essentially a staff officer, not a battlefield commander. Outstandingly brave as a younger officer in the late-nineteenth-century colonial wars, his greatest moment had come in the Boer War, where, as an acting lieutenant general, he had served as Kitchener’s chief of staff. In a military career filled with achievement, Hamilton had never commanded a division or corps in a major campaign. Upon receiving his appointment to command the Mediterranean Expeditionary Force, Hamilton assembled a makeshift staff and left immediately for Gallipoli in HMS Phaeton, a Royal Navy cruiser capable of making thirty knots. In his briefcase he carried a travelogue and an out-of-date book on the Turkish army—all the intelligence that could be provided by the Imperial General Staff. He arrived in time to see the naval defeat of 18 March, when three obsolete battleships—Ocean, Irresistible, and the French Bouvet—went to the bottom with more than seven hundred sailors after striking the Turkish minefields.

The Allied forces assembling in the eastern Mediterranean faced daunting obstacles as they readied themselves for the amphibious assault on Gallipoli. No accurate maps or reliable information about the enemy were available. Moreover, with less than a month remaining before the scheduled 25 April landing, none would be forthcoming. None of the Allied troops had been trained in amphibious operations, which were in any case rudimentary since no doctrine or specialized equipment such as assault landing craft existed. The operation was makeshift in every sense of the word. Still, the Allied soldiers and sailors at Gallipoli belonged to professional armies and navies with great experience and strong traditions, and, at least in the beginning, Allied confidence was high.

The Turks Dig In

At the start of the campaign, Gallipoli was garrisoned by eleven forts with seventy-two guns between them, along with floating minefields and antisubmarine nets spread across the Narrows. The heavier guns were sited at Kum Kale and Sedd el Bahr at the mouth of the Straits. The Germans added eight 6-inch howitzer batteries that could change position rapidly and eight searchlights. Another hundred guns were deployed along the peninsula’s eastern coast, although only ten were relatively modern and the Turks were short on ammunition.

With an Allied invasion clearly in the wind, von Sanders requested and received reinforcements. He departed Constantinople without his staff on 25 March. Arriving in the town of Gallipoli the next day, he immediately began to prepare to defend the peninsula. Recognizing that he could not defend everywhere, von Sanders predicted that Bulair, at the neck of the peninsula, and the beaches of Kum Kale on the Asiatic side would be the main Allied landing sites. This approach was sound and logical as those places provided the best opportunity to land large land forces and the best chance of moving inland successfully. Perhaps the Allies would have been better off pursuing this course of action.

Nevertheless, the outspoken Kemal disagreed, arguing that the brunt of the invasion would come at the center of the peninsula, at the base of the Sari Bair. He expected the Allies to land midway up the peninsula on the western side (avoiding the artillery massed in the Narrows), advance to clear the high ground, and rupture the Turkish defense without attacking it head-on. At the same time, he predicted the British would make a supporting attack from the southern tip of Gallipoli at Cape Helles and move northward to join the units making the main attack at the peninsula’s center.

The Turks finished digging in by the third week in April. All that remained was to wait and watch.

“Now God Be Thanked”

Arriving without a plan, Hamilton and his chief of staff, Major General Braithwaite, extemporized. Hamilton intended to land his best division, the regular army 29th under General Hunter-Weston, on five small beaches at Cape Helles at the extreme southern tip of the peninsula. Ostensibly they were to seize the heights of the most prominent piece of high ground on the peninsula, Achi Baba, located six miles inland. General Birdwood’s Australia–New Zealand Army Corps (ANZAC) was to conduct an amphibious assault nearly thirteen miles farther north between Gaba Tepe and the Sari Bair chain of hills. The ANZACs were then expected to clear the enemy in zone through the Sari Bair hills. Their objective was to reach Mal Tepe in the center of the peninsula.
From Booklist:
Eleven solid historical essays by 11 serving or retired army officers discuss as many twentieth-century military operations. Colonel Dan Bolger (on Liberia) and Colonel John Antal (on Singapore and Chechenya) have previously published fiction as well as nonfiction and may be known to more readers than the other contributors. Meanwhile, editor Hooker recounts an epic defense, that of the German 3rd Mountain Division at Narvik, Norway, in 1940, which would be better known had it been executed by a more respected army. Dana Pittard, Peter Mansoor, and John Tien study the outstanding armored tactics of Rommel in France, the U.S. 4th Armored Division in the same country four years later, and the Battle of 73 Easting in the first Gulf War. J. R. McDonough clearly and dispassionately treats the kind of military situation more likely to be encountered in the modern world in his study of Rwanda, which demonstrates that low-tech weaponry and determination can accomplish mass murder as well as more mediagenic "WMDs" can. Excellent for sophisticated students of warfare. Roland Green
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

"About this title" may belong to another edition of this title.

Shipping: US$ 12.73
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.

Destination, rates & speeds

Add to Basket

Other Popular Editions of the Same Title

9780891417576: By Their Deeds Alone: America's Combat Commanders on the Art of War

Featured Edition

ISBN 10:  ISBN 13:  9780891417576
Publisher: Presidio Press, 2002
Hardcover

Top Search Results from the AbeBooks Marketplace

Stock Image

Hooker, Richard D. (Editor)
Published by Presidio Pr (2003)
ISBN 10: 0891418075 ISBN 13: 9780891418078
New Paperback Quantity: 1
Seller:
Revaluation Books
(Exeter, United Kingdom)

Book Description Paperback. Condition: Brand New. new edition edition. 272 pages. 8.25x5.25x0.50 inches. In Stock. Seller Inventory # __0891418075

More information about this seller | Contact seller

Buy New
US$ 13.39
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 12.73
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds
Stock Image

Richard Hooker
Published by Presidio Press (2004)
ISBN 10: 0891418075 ISBN 13: 9780891418078
New PAP Quantity: 1
Seller:
PBShop.store UK
(Fairford, GLOS, United Kingdom)

Book Description PAP. Condition: New. New Book. Shipped from UK. Established seller since 2000. Seller Inventory # CA-9780891418078

More information about this seller | Contact seller

Buy New
US$ 14.55
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 31.83
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds
Stock Image

Richard Hooker
Published by Presidio Press, New York (2004)
ISBN 10: 0891418075 ISBN 13: 9780891418078
New Paperback Quantity: 1
Seller:
AussieBookSeller
(Truganina, VIC, Australia)

Book Description Paperback. Condition: new. Paperback. In this unique anthology, current or former American combat commanders write with clarity and honesty about key battles that demonstrate important aspects of the art of war. Written with ground-level familiarity which can only come from experience this invaluable collection brings together stories of many well known major battles as well as clashes that have been forgotten, lost from popular memory, until now. Among the contributors are well-known Presidio authors such as John Antal, Daniel Bolger, Jim McDonough, and Robert Leonhard. Editor Richard Hooker Jr. is an army lieutenant colonel currently assigned to the Pentagon as special assistant to the secretary of the army and a noted writer on military affairs. In this unique anthology, current or former American combat commanders write with clarity and honesty about key battles that demonstrate important aspects of the art of war. Shipping may be from our Sydney, NSW warehouse or from our UK or US warehouse, depending on stock availability. Seller Inventory # 9780891418078

More information about this seller | Contact seller

Buy New
US$ 24.98
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 37.00
From Australia to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds
Seller Image

Richard Hooker
Published by Presidio Press, New York (2004)
ISBN 10: 0891418075 ISBN 13: 9780891418078
New Paperback Quantity: 1
Seller:
CitiRetail
(Stevenage, United Kingdom)

Book Description Paperback. Condition: new. Paperback. In this unique anthology, current or former American combat commanders write with clarity and honesty about key battles that demonstrate important aspects of the art of war. Written with ground-level familiarity which can only come from experience this invaluable collection brings together stories of many well known major battles as well as clashes that have been forgotten, lost from popular memory, until now. Among the contributors are well-known Presidio authors such as John Antal, Daniel Bolger, Jim McDonough, and Robert Leonhard. Editor Richard Hooker Jr. is an army lieutenant colonel currently assigned to the Pentagon as special assistant to the secretary of the army and a noted writer on military affairs. In this unique anthology, current or former American combat commanders write with clarity and honesty about key battles that demonstrate important aspects of the art of war. Shipping may be from our UK warehouse or from our Australian or US warehouses, depending on stock availability. Seller Inventory # 9780891418078

More information about this seller | Contact seller

Buy New
US$ 19.66
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 47.11
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds