More Than Skin Deep: Exploring the Real Reasons Why Women Go Under the Knife - Hardcover

Eskenazi, Dr. Loren; Streep, Peg

Hardcover

ISBN 10: 0060577886 ISBN 13: 9780060577889

Publisher: Harper, 2007

Synopsis

Dr. Eskenazi, a nationally recognized expert on breast reconstruction after cancer, began her medical career believing that she would become a psychiatrist. Her interest in psychology combined with a lifelong study of art, mythology, and anthropology has given her an unusual window into the interior landscape of her patients. What she has found is that the desire for external transformation through surgery is connected to internal transformation, most particularly at key moments of transition in a woman's life. Although some eight million women a year have some sort of procedure done, cosmetic surgery is still identified with excessive vanity, narcissism, lack of authenticity, and psychological weakness with the path of least resistance being to deny having had it. By framing cosmetic surgery in a more deeply spiritual and psychological way, Eskenazi takes on this culture of shame and refutes the idea that cosmetic surgery and internal change are antithetical. Whether women decide to have cosmetic surgery or not, this book will provide them with a different vision and a context for understanding their decision.

About this title

About the Authors

Loren Eskenazi, M.D., F.A.C.S., is a nationally known Stanford-trained plastic surgeon and an artist. She is the founding partner of a three-woman clinical practice in San Francisco and the author of Reconstructing Aphrodite. More information about Dr. Eskenazi's approach to increasing conscious healing through cosmetic and reconstructive surgery can be found on her website:

Peg Streep is both the daughter of a mean mother and the devoted mother of an adult daughter. She is the author or coauthor of nine books, including Girl in the Mirror: Mothers and Daughters in the Years of Adolescence and the bestselling Necessary Journeys: Letting Ourselves Learn from Life, both with Dr. Nancy L. Snyderman. Streep holds degrees in English from the University of Pennsylvania and Columbia University. A native New Yorker, she is married and lives in Burlington, Vermont.

From the Back Cover

Dr. Eskenazi, a nationally recognized expert on breast reconstruction after cancer, began her medical career believing that she would become a psychiatrist. Her interest in psychology combined with a lifelong study of art, mythology, and anthropology has given her an unusual window into the interior landscape of her patients. What she has found is that the desire for external transformation through surgery is connected to internal transformation, most particularly at key moments of transition in a woman's life. Although some eight million women a year have some sort of procedure done, cosmetic surgery is still identified with excessive vanity, narcissism, lack of authenticity, and psychological weakness with the path of least resistance being to deny having had it. By framing cosmetic surgery in a more deeply spiritual and psychological way, Eskenazi takes on this culture of shame and refutes the idea that cosmetic surgery and internal change are antithetical. Whether women decide to have cosmetic surgery or not, this book will provide them with a different vision and a context for understanding their decision.

Reviews

San Francisco plastic surgeon Eskenazi denies that most of her female patients who undergo breast enlargements, face-lifts, liposuction and other cosmetic operations are insecure dupes of an ageist, "female-hating culture." Rather, cosmetic surgery is but a modern version of an ancient rite of passage that celebrates life stages by marking the flesh, thereby filling "the hole left in the fabric of our communal life by the loss of ritual." Like the ancient initiate, the modern patient leaves her identity behind as she strips off her street clothes, is purified by antibacterial scrubs, prostrates herself on the altar of the operating table, undergoes a death/rebirth sequence of anesthesia and wakes up to a body that is marked and transformed. To this end, Eskenazi's patients work with ritualists and psychotherapists, keep dream journals, build altars, practice meditation and create prayers to accompany surgery. Aided by Streep (Necessary Journeys), Eskenazi posits an interesting myth-infused approach that will be embraced by like-minded readers. Others will see this as preposterous New Age babble served up by a rationalizing doctor who wants to see herself as a shaman and her patients' desire for bigger breasts as a spiritual, high-minded quest. (Feb. 6)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

The number of cosmetic procedures balloons (more than 10,000 nationwide in 2005), yet those seeking to alter their appearance continue to be scorned and derided. Whether accounted to vanity, artificial notions of beauty, or pressure from a man, women's perceived reasons for seeking cosmetic surgery are often written off as superficial or, worse, manipulated and orchestrated. Female plastic surgeon Eskenazi scoffs at such criticisms, made as if women were incapable of making informed, intelligent decisions about their appearance. She has heard all the hoary arguments and responds to them with a stern reminder of the powerful--and newly confirmed in Western medicine--mind-body connection. Linking historical practices of body marking and reshaping with the spiritual importance of ritual observances of life passages, she makes such a strong case in favor of cosmetic surgery that it seems a shame for women not to use it at, say, puberty, menopause, and the successful conclusion of a bitter divorce. She cautions, however, that cosmetic surgery isn't to be undertaken without considering serious spiritual and physical factors. Donna Chavez
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.

More Than Skin Deep

Exploring the Real Reasons Why Women Go Under the KnifeBy Loren Eskenazi

HarperCollins Publishers, Inc.

Copyright © 2007 Loren Eskenazi
All right reserved.
ISBN: 9780060577889

Chapter One

Cosmetic Surgery and the Promise of Transformation

Some twenty-five years ago, I went to medical school to become a healer. I chose plastic surgery because the transformation it offered patients was immediate and life-changing. As a young medical student, I witnessed cleft lips made whole, birth defects rectified, and missing body parts re-created, and I fell in love with the extraordinary promise offered by the specialty. I traveled to foreign countries as part of a surgical team that in real and visible ways altered the lives of hundreds of adults and children over the course of a few weeks. I saw that each life and each surgery was unique, and I felt sure and confident that this was medicine at its finest and most personally fulfilling.

Now, having performed roughly ten thousand surgeries and undergone three procedures myself, I spend my days as the founding partner in an all-women's practice in San Francisco, where I devote half my time to breast reconstruction after cancer and half to cosmetic surgery in all its forms. I now see that the healing we offer as surgeons isn't always as clear-cut as it once appeared, and that cosmetic surgery raises questions and concerns I didn't anticipate when I was just beginning.

I've grown troubled as cosmetic surgery increasingly becomes, with each passing year, a commodity in American life, a readily available answer to dissatisfaction with all aspects of the physical self. Where it was once the province of the rich and famous, it's been fully democratized. It no longer needs to be done in Beverly Hills or Manhattan or cost a fortune, and more and more women each year from all over the country are choosing it. Information about procedures as well as local advertising from doctors offering their services are readily available on the Internet, testifying to the ubiquity of this surgery. Type in "cosmetic surgery" on Google and you'll get more than 1.5 million matches.

Each year, more and more American women elect to have cosmetic surgery, and the trend shows no sign of abating. More than 10 million surgical and nonsurgical procedures were performed on women in 2005, and by the time you read this, the number will undoubtedly be higher, as it has been with each passing year—a reflection of cosmetic surgery both as a cultural fact and a phenomenon. It has become a reliable growth business: In a single year—between 2003 and 2004—the number of abdominoplasties increased by 28 percent, the number of breast lifts 19 percent, the number of liposuctions 28 percent. In 2004 the number of breast augmentations went up 9 percent, and the abdominoplasties another 12 percent.1 This growth shows that cosmetic surgery has become just another product in our consumer society.

These are seismic changes and are having an effect on our culture and how we think about beauty, age, and our bodies. But we don't appear to have developed the philosophical tools we need to understand how these changes can help us live better and more fulfilled lives in the future or how these changes may, in the alternative, make personal happiness more elusive.

I actually had the opportunity to see how quickly attitudes toward cosmetic surgery changed when I participated in teaching a course in biomedical ethics at Stanford University in the early 1990s. I lectured undergraduates on body modification and plastic surgery for several years, and during that time, I witnessed an extraordinary shift in attitudes. The first year I taught, I asked my students if they would ever consider plastic surgery, and their answer was a resounding "No way!" They were judgmental about people who chose to alter their appearance. The second year, the answer was still a categorical no, but this time, a number of students knew someone who had had surgery and they were mildly curious about the possible benefits plastic surgery could bestow. Astonishingly, by the third year, one-half of the class answered that they would, indeed, opt for surgical improvement, although they remained troubled by how plastic surgery had the potential to install uniform standards of beauty in a culture. By the fourth year, when I asked the question, the class was solidly in favor of cosmetic surgery and said they would absolutely avail themselves of it; their only caveat was cost. In fact, by then, they thought it should be covered by health insurance. For better or worse, young people are more flexible than their elders.

For our children and their children, cosmetic surgery will actively shape how our culture defines feminine beauty, assesses physical "perfection," and responds to the process of aging. In the face of a growing demand for the improvement and refinement of the physical characteristics we're born and age with, my profession will continue to be motivated to seek out new techniques, which will, in turn, bring in more patients. In the future, we'll be seeing the patient pool—now concentrated between the ages of thirty-six and sixty-four, with the majority of women between forty-five and fifty-five—get younger as procedures are performed earlier to stave off the early signs of aging and as "proactive" surgery becomes the norm.

While this should make me feel good about a wise career choice, it gives me pause.

As a woman, a doctor, and a patient, I feel we've reached an important watershed moment. Contradictions abound when it comes to cosmetic surgery. First, for all that Americans seem fascinated by and drawn to the promise of improvement that cosmetic surgery offers, they also believe that those who choose it are weak and insecure. Even as scientific research begins to decipher the complex relationship between the mind and the body, popular culture continues to insist that the mind and the body are separate and that the "mind" is morally superior to the body. What this means in practical terms is that women who choose to have cosmetic surgery for reasons that might be healthy and self-affirming will nonetheless be stereotyped as vain or overly concerned with appearance. As a result, there's no dialogue about how changing the body can and does change the "self" or the mind—even though there is plenty of scientific evidence at hand.

Continues...

Excerpted from More Than Skin Deepby Loren Eskenazi Copyright © 2007 by Loren Eskenazi. Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Edition details

• Publisher: Harper
• Publication date: 2007
• Language: English
• ISBN 10: 0060577886
• ISBN 13: 9780060577889
• Binding: Hardcover
• Edition number: 1
• Number of pages: 176