On Constitutional Disobedience (Inalienable Rights)

3.77 avg rating
( 31 ratings by Goodreads )
 
9780199898275: On Constitutional Disobedience (Inalienable Rights)
View all copies of this ISBN edition:
 
 

What would the Framers of the Constitution make of multinational corporations? Nuclear weapons? Gay marriage? They led a preindustrial country, much of it dependent on slave labor, huddled on the Atlantic seaboard. The Founders saw society as essentially hierarchical, led naturally by landed gentry like themselves. Yet we still obey their commands, two centuries and one civil war later. According to Louis Michael Seidman, it's time to stop.

In On Constitutional Disobedience, Seidman argues that, in order to bring our basic law up to date, it needs benign neglect. This is a highly controversial assertion. The doctrine of "original intent" may be found on the far right, but the entire political spectrum--left and right--shares a deep reverence for the Constitution. And yet, Seidman reminds us, disobedience is the original intent of the Constitution. The Philadelphia convention had gathered to amend the Articles of Confederation, not toss them out and start afresh. The "living Constitution" school tries to bridge the gap between the framers and ourselves by reinterpreting the text in light of modern society's demands. But this attempt is doomed, Seidman argues. One might stretch "due process of law" to protect an act of same-sex sodomy, yet a loyal-but-contemporary reading cannot erase the fact that the Constitution allows a candidate who lost the popular election to be seated as president. And that is only one of the gross violations of popular will enshrined in the document. Seidman systematically addresses and refutes the arguments in favor of Constitutional fealty, proposing instead that it be treated as inspiration, not a set of commands.

The Constitution is, at its best, a piece of poetry to liberty and self-government. If we treat it as such, the author argues, we will make better progress in achieving both.

"synopsis" may belong to another edition of this title.

Review:

Q&A with Louis Seidman, author of On Constitutional Disobedience

Q. What do you think are the greatest flaws with our Constitution?

A. The biggest problem with the Constitution is the amendment process outlined in Article V. It is extremely cumbersome. In fact, the American constitution is more difficult to amend than any other national constitution in the world. As a practical matter, it means that under present political circumstances the Constitution is unamendable. This means that we are saddled with a bunch of eighteenth century judgments about twenty-first century problems.

Q. What is your proposed process for revising the US Constitution?

A. I’m not in favor of revising the Constitution. I am in favor of ignoring it. The basic argument that I make is that the United States is owned by the people presently living in it. We would not want a foreign government or the UN telling us how to run our country, and we should not want people long dead to tell us either. Just as it is wrong for these people to tell us what kind of country we should have, so too it would be wrong for us to dictate to future generations.

Q. Where does Constitutional Disobedience fall within the various schools of constitutional thought? (i.e. originalism vs. living constitutionalism)

A. Originalism is the view that the constitution should be interpreted according to the original public meaning of the text or the original understanding of the framers. This approach is often impractical. Does the first amendment apply to video games or to internet chat rooms? Neither the words of the first amendment nor the intent of the framers can answer questions like this because the people writing those words did not conceive of these developments. More fundamentally, originalism forces us to obey commands that are frequently obsolete and sometimes morally odious. Living constitutionalism tries to avoid these problems by giving modern interpretations to the text. The problem with this approach is that it pretty much lets us do whatever we want to do. I have no problem with this in principle, but I do think that advocates of this approach should be honest about what they are doing: insisting that we comply with their judgments, rather than judgments derived from the Constitution’s text. I favor neither interpretive approach because I think the Constitution should be ignored rather than interpreted. This is not to say that we should disregard all the provisions that are in the Constitution. Many of these provisions are wise and just. The point is that we should obey them to the extent that and because they are wise and just, not because they are in the Constitution.

Q. How does your argument fit in with the current gun control debate?

A. As it happens, I am quite skeptical about most forms of gun control, but not because of judgments made two hundred twenty five years ago in a social context radically different from our own. What we should be debating is whether gun control makes sense in a modern context. When the debate is constitutionalized, it is turned over to lawyers, and lawyers do with it what lawyers do generally — focus very carefully on language like the original meaning of “militia” and “bear arms” and the legislative history of the second amendment. These subjects are completely beside the point. Investigation of them distracts us from the issues that should matter to us while simultaneously raising the temperature of the debate by suggesting that our opponents are being unfaithful to foundational American values.

About the Author:


Louis Michael Seidman is Carmack Waterhouse Professor of Constitutional Law at Georgetown University. His books include Our Unsettled Constitution, Equal Protection of the Laws, and Silence and Freedom.

"About this title" may belong to another edition of this title.

Buy New View Book
List Price: US$ 26.95
US$ 9.96

Convert currency

Shipping: FREE
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.

Destination, rates & speeds

Add to Basket

Top Search Results from the AbeBooks Marketplace

1.

Louis Michael Seidman
Published by Oxford University Press Inc, United States (2013)
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 10
Seller:
Book Depository International
(London, United Kingdom)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press Inc, United States, 2013. Hardback. Condition: New. New. Language: English. Brand new Book. What would the Framers of the Constitution make of multinational corporations? Nuclear weapons? Gay marriage? They led a preindustrial country, much of it dependent on slave labor, huddled on the Atlantic seaboard. The Founders saw society as essentially hierarchical, led naturally by landed gentry like themselves. Yet we still obey their commands, two centuries and one civil war later. According to Louis Michael Seidman, it's time to stop. In On Constitutional Disobedience, Seidman argues that, in order to bring our basic law up to date, it needs benign neglect. This is a highly controversial assertion. The doctrine of "original intent" may be found on the far right, but the entire political spectrum-left and right-shares a deep reverence for the Constitution. And yet, Seidman reminds us, disobedience is the original intent of the Constitution. The Philadelphia convention had gathered to amend the Articles ofConfederation, not toss them out and start afresh. The "living Constitution" school tries to bridge the gap between the framers and ourselves by reinterpreting the text in light of modern society's demands. But this attempt is doomed, Seidman argues. One might stretch "due process of law" to protect an act of same-sexsodomy, yet a loyal-but-contemporary reading cannot erase the fact that the Constitution allows a candidate who lost the popular election to be seated as president. And that is only one of the gross violations of popular will enshrined in the document. Seidman systematically addresses and refutes the arguments in favor of Constitutional fealty, proposing instead that it be treated as inspiration, not a set of commands. The Constitution is, at its best, a piece of poetry to liberty and self-government. If we treat it as such, the author argues, we will make better progress in achieving both. Seller Inventory # POW9780199898275

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 9.96
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: FREE
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

2.

Louis Michael Seidman
Published by Oxford University Press Inc, United States (2013)
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 10
Seller:
The Book Depository
(London, United Kingdom)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press Inc, United States, 2013. Hardback. Condition: New. New. Language: English. Brand new Book. What would the Framers of the Constitution make of multinational corporations? Nuclear weapons? Gay marriage? They led a preindustrial country, much of it dependent on slave labor, huddled on the Atlantic seaboard. The Founders saw society as essentially hierarchical, led naturally by landed gentry like themselves. Yet we still obey their commands, two centuries and one civil war later. According to Louis Michael Seidman, it's time to stop. In On Constitutional Disobedience, Seidman argues that, in order to bring our basic law up to date, it needs benign neglect. This is a highly controversial assertion. The doctrine of "original intent" may be found on the far right, but the entire political spectrum-left and right-shares a deep reverence for the Constitution. And yet, Seidman reminds us, disobedience is the original intent of the Constitution. The Philadelphia convention had gathered to amend the Articles ofConfederation, not toss them out and start afresh. The "living Constitution" school tries to bridge the gap between the framers and ourselves by reinterpreting the text in light of modern society's demands. But this attempt is doomed, Seidman argues. One might stretch "due process of law" to protect an act of same-sexsodomy, yet a loyal-but-contemporary reading cannot erase the fact that the Constitution allows a candidate who lost the popular election to be seated as president. And that is only one of the gross violations of popular will enshrined in the document. Seidman systematically addresses and refutes the arguments in favor of Constitutional fealty, proposing instead that it be treated as inspiration, not a set of commands. The Constitution is, at its best, a piece of poetry to liberty and self-government. If we treat it as such, the author argues, we will make better progress in achieving both. Seller Inventory # POW9780199898275

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 10.29
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: FREE
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

3.

Seidman, Louis Michael
Published by Oxford University Press
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 1
Seller:
Mesilla Internet
(Mesilla, NM, U.S.A.)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press. Hardcover. Condition: New. 0199898278 New. Seller Inventory # Z0199898278ZN

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 8.98
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 3.48
Within U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

4.

Louis Michael Seidman
Published by Oxford University Press (2013)
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 1
Seller:
Irish Booksellers
(Portland, ME, U.S.A.)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press, 2013. Condition: New. book. Seller Inventory # M0199898278

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 18.79
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 3.27
Within U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

5.

Louis Michael Seidman
Published by Oxford University Press (2013)
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 1
Seller:
Irish Booksellers
(Portland, ME, U.S.A.)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press, 2013. Condition: New. book. Seller Inventory # MB010WHFOFQ

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 18.79
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 3.27
Within U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

6.

Louis Michael Seidman
Published by Oxford University Press Inc, United States (2013)
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 10
Seller:
Book Depository hard to find
(London, United Kingdom)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press Inc, United States, 2013. Hardback. Condition: New. New. Language: English. Brand new Book. What would the Framers of the Constitution make of multinational corporations? Nuclear weapons? Gay marriage? They led a preindustrial country, much of it dependent on slave labor, huddled on the Atlantic seaboard. The Founders saw society as essentially hierarchical, led naturally by landed gentry like themselves. Yet we still obey their commands, two centuries and one civil war later. According to Louis Michael Seidman, it's time to stop. In On Constitutional Disobedience, Seidman argues that, in order to bring our basic law up to date, it needs benign neglect. This is a highly controversial assertion. The doctrine of "original intent" may be found on the far right, but the entire political spectrum-left and right-shares a deep reverence for the Constitution. And yet, Seidman reminds us, disobedience is the original intent of the Constitution. The Philadelphia convention had gathered to amend the Articles ofConfederation, not toss them out and start afresh. The "living Constitution" school tries to bridge the gap between the framers and ourselves by reinterpreting the text in light of modern society's demands. But this attempt is doomed, Seidman argues. One might stretch "due process of law" to protect an act of same-sexsodomy, yet a loyal-but-contemporary reading cannot erase the fact that the Constitution allows a candidate who lost the popular election to be seated as president. And that is only one of the gross violations of popular will enshrined in the document. Seidman systematically addresses and refutes the arguments in favor of Constitutional fealty, proposing instead that it be treated as inspiration, not a set of commands. The Constitution is, at its best, a piece of poetry to liberty and self-government. If we treat it as such, the author argues, we will make better progress in achieving both. Seller Inventory # BZV9780199898275

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 30.49
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: FREE
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

7.

Louis Michael Seidman
Published by Oxford University Press
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 5
Seller:
THE SAINT BOOKSTORE
(Southport, United Kingdom)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press. Hardback. Condition: New. New copy - Usually dispatched within 2 working days. Seller Inventory # B9780199898275

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 23.80
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 9.15
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

8.

ON CONSTITUTIONAL DISOBEDIENCE (HARDBACK) -
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Quantity Available: 1
Seller:
Herb Tandree Philosophy Books
(Stroud, GLOS, United Kingdom)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Condition: NEW. 9780199898275 This listing is a new book, a title currently in-print which we order directly and immediately from the publisher. For all enquiries, please contact Herb Tandree Philosophy Books directly - customer service is our primary goal. Seller Inventory # HTANDREE01550084

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 27.83
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 10.55
From United Kingdom to U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

9.

Seidman, Louis Michael
Published by Oxford University Press (2013)
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Hardcover Quantity Available: 2
Seller:
Murray Media
(NORTH MIAMI BEACH, FL, U.S.A.)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Oxford University Press, 2013. Hardcover. Condition: New. Never used!. Seller Inventory # P110199898278

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 52.74
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: FREE
Within U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

10.

Louis Michael Seidman
ISBN 10: 0199898278 ISBN 13: 9780199898275
New Quantity Available: 1
Seller:
BennettBooksLtd
(San Diego, CA, U.S.A.)
Rating
[?]

Book Description Condition: New. New. Seller Inventory # STRM-0199898278

More information about this seller | Contact this seller

Buy New
US$ 78.80
Convert currency

Add to Basket

Shipping: US$ 4.95
Within U.S.A.
Destination, rates & speeds

There are more copies of this book

View all search results for this book