Under the Shadow of Napoleon: French Influence on the American Way of Warfare from Independence to the Eve of World War II (Warfare and Culture, 3) - Hardcover

Bonura, Michael

Hardcover

ISBN 10: 0814709427 ISBN 13: 9780814709429

Publisher: NYU Press, 2012

Synopsis

The way an army thinks about and understands warfare has a tremendous impact on its organization, training, and operations. The central ideas of that understanding form a nation's way of warfare that influences decisions on and off the battlefield. From the disasters of the War of 1812, Winfield Scott ensured that America adopted a series of ideas formed in the crucible of the Wars of the French Revolution and epitomized by Napoleon. Reflecting American cultural changes, these French ideas dominated American warfare on the battlefields of the Mexican-American War, the American Civil War, the Spanish-American War, and World War I. America remained committed to these ideas until cultural pressures and the successes of German Blitzkrieg from 1939 - 1940 led George C. Marshall to orchestrate the adoption of a different understanding of warfare. Michael A. Bonura examines concrete battlefield tactics, army regulations, and theoretical works on war as they were presented in American army education manuals, professional journals, and the popular press, to demonstrate that as a cultural construction, warfare and ways of warfare can be transnational and influence other nations.

About this title

About the Author:

Michael A. Bonura is a Major in the United States Army. From 2006 to 2009, he was an Instructor and Assistant Professor at the United States Military Academy in West Point, NY. He has been a contributing member of the Consortium on the Revolutionary Era, the annual conference for Napoleonic and French Revolutionary history, the annual meeting of the Society for Military History as well as numerous other international Napoleonic conferences. Major Bonura continues to research and publish as an independent scholar.

Review:

"This is one of the most compelling works to date on the early and ongoing development of a professional US Army...  For these reasons, and despite the flaws of its overall thesis, I highly recommend Under the Shadow of Napoleon. Studies of the intellectual history of the US Army are few and far between, and Bonura's thorough, well-written account of tactical level developments can be placed alongside the strategic studies by Russell Weigley and Brian Linn. That's not bad company." Thomas A. Bruscino Jr., US Army School of Advanced Military Studies, Michigan War Studies Review (MiWSR.com)

"As an active serving officer and a trained historian, Michael Bonura has written an excellent volume analyzing the French method and Napoleonic system of war as it applied to the American method of warfare during the formative years.  Tracing the impact of this system upon the education of cadets and officers trained at West Point and the other military schools, on the army administration, its publications and military exercises as well as in the actual wars fought by America, Bonura has produced in invaluable study in understanding the evolution of America's method of war."-Donald D. Horward,Founding Director. Institute on Napoleon and the French Revolution

"The debate over the existence of an 'American way of war' continues, and never has it had more urgency than it does today. Now, active duty officer Michael Bonura reminds us of the crucial role played by French Revolutionary and Napoleonic methods. As he argues convincingly, admiration for the 'French combat method' first took hold at West Point, spread throughout the army in the 19th century, and remained its lodestar until the very eve of World War II. Bonura presents an army that talked constantly of change and transformation, but remained largely consistent in its methods over time. This thought-provoking and well researched book is essential for anyone interested in the U.S. Army, the evolution of military doctrine, and, above all, the role that West Point has played in the army’s development."-Robert Citino,Military History Center, University of North Texas

"Bonura makes a provocative argument for the primacy of French and Napoleonic military thinking on American tactical development prior to World War II. His research provides convincing evidence of both the intellectual conservatism and the fixation on battle that have shaped the Army’s way of war."-Brian M. Linn,Ralph R. Thomas Professor in Liberal Arts, Texas A&M University

About this edition

• Publisher: NYU Press
• Publication date: 2012
• ISBN 10: 0814709427
• ISBN 13: 9780814709429
• Binding: Hardcover
• Number of pages: 318