Questioning: A Multidimensional Critique - Softcover

Softcover

ISBN 10: 0830827692 ISBN 13: 9780830827695

Publisher: IVP Academic, 2004

Synopsis

One need not undertake a very close reading of the Gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke to recognize that they have much in common. But what are the origins of their literary relationship? The nineteenth and twentieth centuries saw considerable energy devoted to this question. Early hypotheses supposed a primitive proto-Gospel to have been the source for all three Synoptics, but later theories envisioned two sources--an early version of Mark and a sayings-source document eventually dubbed Q. In contemporary Gospel studies, Q has taken on a quasi-factual status, resulting in such publications as The Critical Edition of Q, complete with critical apparatus. This textualization of Q has taken place despite the fact that Q has never been found, we have no manuscripts of Q, and no church fathers attest that such a document ever existed. In Questioning Q editors Mark Goodacre and Nicholas Perrin introduce a diverse network of scholars who examine the Q hypothesis from a variety of perspectives--historical, literary, source-critical and redactional--and ask ultimately, Can we dispense with Q? and What would a world without Q look like? Even the most ardent and articulate defenders of Q will benefit from this well-reasoned, respectful challenge to an oft-unexamined assumption.

Edition details

• Publisher: IVP Academic
• Publication date: 2004
• Language: English
• ISBN 10: 0830827692
• ISBN 13: 9780830827695
• Binding: Paperback
• Number of pages: 201
• Editor: Goodacre Mark, Perrin Nicholas