Going Wild: Hunting, Animal Rights, and the Contested Meaning of Nature - Hardcover

Dizard, Jan E.

Hardcover

ISBN 10: 0870239082 ISBN 13: 9780870239083

Publisher: University of Massachusetts Press, 1994

Synopsis

First published in 1994, Going Wild offers a probing examination of the ways in which different conceptions of nature shape our responses to specific environmental issues. In this revised edition, Jan E. Dizard adds a thoughtful and extensive new chapter, updating the controversy over the state-managed deer hunt at the Quabbin Reservoir in Massachusetts and placing it in a broader national context.

About this title

About the Author

Professor of sociology and American studies at Amherst College, Jan E. Dizard is coauthor of The Minimal Family (University of Massachusetts Press, 1990).

Reviews

The impassioned debate on deer hunting staged here by Dizard, a professor of sociology and American studies at Amherst College, raises pros and cons beyond the fiery local issue. In 1991, after volcanic hearings, Metropolitan District Commission (MDC) officials opened 55,000 acres surrounding the Quabbin Reservoir in Western Massachusetts, Boston's major water source, to a nine-day deer hunt. The first day, 300 eager hunters killed 123 deer; 900 hunters killed a total of 576 by the ninth day. In an agile, well-focused narrative, Dizard explores the intellectual machinations justifying the hunt while delineating the underpinnings of how we view nature. The Quabbin is a spectacular example for this exploration; the woodlands around the reservoir were "completely contrived," eventually developing into an "idealized, tame wilderness." To his credit, Dizard sketches a broad canvas of subfactions, from demonstrators with placards reading "Meat is Murder" to honorable hunters sneering at cohorts slaughtering tame animals. In between, supporters claim the hunt was necessary because deer were eating new growth in the forest that protects the water supply; critics say the MDC wants to continue logging for revenue. Beneath the controversy smolder larger contending views. Should nature be seen as a self-balancing harmony or a challenge to use and dominate? Who decides what is wild? In short, is wildlife management an oxymoron? For those arming with arguments from both sides, this book is indeed mind-stretching and valuable.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.

Absorbing study of an environmental dispute at the Quabbin Reservoir, located west of Boston. In the early 1990s, officials in charge of the reservoir decided to hold a restricted deer hunt. Deer populations had become so large that officials feared they threatened the whole area, considered by many to be "wild." Sides quickly formed for and against the hunt. But the book is much more than a sizing up of groups and positions. Dizard argues that what the Quabbin dispute exemplifies are differing views about the very "nature of nature." One side believed that humans are the problem in most environmental issues and need to be kept away from nature. The other side viewed nature as chaotic, and in need of human intervention. The reservoir officials prevailed, but the dispute in the larger sense is far from over. A solid addition to environmental literature, Dizard's book also provides an insightful look at the conflicts between the hunting and animal rights communities. Highly recommended. Brian McCombie

Edition details

• Publisher: University of Massachusetts Press
• Publication date: 1994
• Language: English
• ISBN 10: 0870239082
• ISBN 13: 9780870239083
• Binding: Hardcover
• Number of pages: 200