Myth and History: Ethnicity & Politics in the First Millennium British Isles - Softcover

Yeates, Stephen James

Softcover

ISBN 10: 1842174789 ISBN 13: 9781842174784

Publisher: Oxbow Books, 2012

Synopsis

Our recent understanding of British history has been slowly unraveling thanks to new techniques such as DNA analysis, new archaeological data and reassessment of the literary evidence. There are considerable problems in understanding the early history of Britain; sources for the centuries from the first Roman invasion to 1000 AD are few and contradictory, the archaeological record complex and there is little collaboration or agreement between archaeologists, Roman and Anglo-Saxon historians. A common assumption concerning the development of the English language and, therefore British history, is that there was an invasion from northern Europe in the fifth century, the so-called Anglo-Saxon migration; a model based on the writings of Bede. However the Bedan model has become increasingly unsustainable and is on the verge of collapse.
Myth and History offers a comprehensive reassessment of the present scientific, historical, archaeological and language evidence, debunking the model of British history based on Bede, and showing how Roman texts can be used in conjunction with the other evidence to build an alternative picture. Stephen Yeates demonstrates that the evidence that has been used to construct the story of an Anglo-Saxon migration, with an incoming population replacing most, if not all, of the British population has been found wanting, that initial attempts to interpret literally the DNA evidence based on historical sources are problematic, and that the best DNA analysis of the British Isles fits the evidence into a broader European view which attempts to plot the movement of people across the Continent and which sees the major migration periods in Europe as occurring in the Mesolithic and the Neolithic. This DNA analysis is constant with the latest assessments based on language development, contemporary historical reports from the Roman period, and the analysis of archaeological data from the Iron Age and Roman period. He also argues that the Roman texts can be used to identify where the Late Roman provinces of Britain actually lay and this leads to important conclusions about the ethnicity and origins of the early British peoples. This book is a timely attempt to unravel myth from history, present a cogent platform for Anglo-Saxon studies and understand who the British people really are.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Science
3. Language
4. Part I: Roman History
    Part II: A Time for Myth
    Part III: Medieval History
5. Archaeology
6. The Roman Model: A new Framework

About this title

Review:

Dit alles zorgt ervoor dat dit boek een zeer compleet en aan te raden werk is voor iedereen die onderzoek doet naar vroegmiddeleeuws Groot-Brittanië. (Tino Oudesluijs Kelten)

I agree that the long term history of Britain and its populations is the context within which the fifth-sixth centuries AD needs to be considered. I also agree that the discussion of this period has always been subject to a variety of bias. (Catherine Hills Antiquity, Vol. 87, Issue 338, Dec 2013)

About this edition

• Publisher: Oxbow Books
• Publication date: 2012
• ISBN 10: 1842174789
• ISBN 13: 9781842174784
• Binding: Paperback
• Number of pages: 496