The Forensic Unreliability of the Shaken Baby Syndrome

The author effectively and efficiently organizes controversial scientific topics into chapters heavily footnoted with current references to biomechanics engineering and medical literature, and legal decisions. A highly recommended publication for all practitioners facing cases involving any child abuse allegation. -- Kathleen Pakes, Member of the SPD Forensic Practice Group


The work itself is a masterpiece of simplicity in a frighteningly complicated world. It takes the reader by the hand and takes them through the history of this flawed science arming the practitioner, whether they be lawyer or doctor, with the wherewithal to understand the history of SBS/AHT, the contradictions involved in such a diagnosis, and the material with which to expose this dangerous science. -- Michael Turner QC



This book is the most comprehensive effort to date to explore the science, medicine, and law as they relate to shaken baby syndrome (SBS), abusive head trauma (AHT), and their related controversies. Written by a trial attorney experienced in SBS/AHT cases, and edited by one of the world’s leading forensic pathologists, the book provides physicians, investigators, lawyers, courts—anyone interested in these controversies—with a guide Traces the history of SBS, both in the literature and in the courtroom, its ongoing evolution into AHT, and highlights how proponents of SBS/AHT have shaped and defended SBS to serve child protection and legal purposes; Reviews and summarizes the scientific, medical, and legal literature relating to SBS, AHT, and alternative explanations for the triad findings that may lead to mistaken SBS/AHT diagnoses; Examines the scientific evidence base for the forensic use of SBS, AHT, and retinal hemorrhages; Analyzes the legal reliability of SBS/AHT against the standards of the United States Supreme Court’s Daubert decision.