Challenging the tides: a clear critique of the moon's pull and the Newtonian view
This edition examines historic observations of tides and questions the idea that gravity from the moon and sun dominantly governs tidal rise. It argues that tide tables and real-world data don’t always match the predictions of the Newtonian theory, inviting careful scrutiny of long-held assumptions.
The book surveys observed tides from multiple ports, contrasts published calculations with actual measurements, and names key figures who defended or challenged the theory. It presents a protracted dispute about what drives ocean movement and what methods best reveal the truth.
- Analyzes how tides have been measured and reported in different places and times
- Critiques the idea that gravity alone explains high and low tides
- Names historians and scientists who influenced the tide debate
- Argues for relying on observed data rather than abstract models
Ideal for readers of scientific history, philosophy of science, and anyone curious about how classic theories are tested against real-world evidence.