My Return

My Return is sure to provoke intense public discussion and controversy. The author, Jack Henry Abbott, is now serving a fifteen-years-to-life sentence for the 1981 stabbing of Richard Adan, a young night manager of the Binibon Cafe on Manhattan's Lower East Side.

Only six weeks before killing Adan, Abbott had been paroled from Marion Federal Prison in Illinois at the age of thirty-seven. While in prison, he had become well known as a promising writer, encouraged in his work by Norman Mailer and other New York literati. Abbott's In the Belly of the Beast was released at the time of his parole and was widely heralded as a major literary achievement.

Except for a short-lived escape from prison in 1971, Abbott had been incarcerated in one institution or another since he was thirteen years old. His parole placed him in another potentially violent environment, but one that had a completely different set of rules. He has consistently maintained that he thought Richard Adan was carrying a knife and that his attack on Adan was the result of that perception.

Naomi Zack, who has a Ph.D. in philosophy from Columbia University, became interested in the Abbott case while doing research for a film on the victims of crime and of the criminal justice system. She is convinced that Abbott was unfairly convicted by an outraged public opinion inflamed by sensational treatment in the media.

My Return is Jack Abbott's and Naomi Zack's story of the death of Richard Adan, the ensuing trial, and Abbott's return to prison. It is comprised of "The Death of Tragedy," a play based on the actual court records; an illustrated appendix giving stage directions and the background of the issues and people involved; and "Men of Letters," a collection of Abbott's essays on a variety of topics - religious, philosophical, historical, and literary - including an autobiographical account of his tragic life. It is an absorbing and undeniably fascinating work.

Although it is his story, Jack Henry Abbott receives no royalties or any other remuneration from the publication of this book.

Shortly after his parole and the publication of his In the Belly of the Beast ( LJ 6/1/81), Abbott, who had been championed by Norman Mailer, was convicted of manslaughter in the killing of a New York City cafe employee. Part of this book presents, in the form of a play, Abbott's version of the incident, which he rather persuasively argues was a case of self-defense. The other part consists of essays/letters (including a hostile one to William Styron) mainly about religion. Abbott, a Marxist in Belly , has "converted to Judaism." This reviewer found the essays mostly pretentious and boring, but those who have dismissed Abbott as an incorrigible may want to read his claim of self-defense. Gregor A. Preston, Univ. of California Lib., Davis
Copyright 1987 Reed Business Information, Inc.