The Tree of Knowledge

Elderly widow Deborah Milton, daughter of John Milton, one of England's most celebrated poets, faces interviews with academics and men of letters seeking information on her famous father, in a novel set in early eighteenth century England

English poet John Milton's exploited daughter Deborah is the narrator of this informative but labored fictional reminiscence. While she arouses both pity for herself and indignation at the paternal arrogance and the patriachal system that demeaned her, this treatment of a vital theme by Figes ( Ghosts ; the nonfiction Patriarchal Attitudes ) proves tedious artistically. The title alludes to the learning Milton begrudged women and to the bitter wisdom his daughter now tastes. Deborah was left poorly educated and penniless by the great man for whom she and her sister labored as amanuenses over Paradise Lost. Now white-haired and tending an ailing daughter, she ekes out a pittance by running a school in her home. Scholars barge in at their convenience, avid for souvenirs. Deborah murmurs on garrulously in the sweetly complaining accents of meek Christian fortitude, offering "homespun thoughts and patchwork recollections," pious truisms ("The Lord giveth and the Lord taketh away") and an unconscionably long-winded allegory about politics in terms of wolves and lambs, during which she chides her audience to "sit quiet" and pay attention. The meandering voice descends eventually into madness and incoherence. The book's feminist message is incontrovertible, but the fictional structure flounders.
Copyright 1991 Reed Business Information, Inc.

The narrator in this fictional account is Deborah, daughter of English poet John Milton. Scholars who visit Deborah in her later years find her widowed, poor, and bitter about her life. Because she was female, she never received an education. She learned to pronounce words in foreign languages so that she could read to her blind father, but she was never taught what the words meant. In answering questions about her father, she paints a vivid picture of the early 17th century--cold, hard, bleak, and tragic. Deborah longs for the knowledge denied her by an accident of birth. The style of narrative captures the history of the era and the struggle of this elderly woman to make peace with herself. Recommended.
- Joanna M. Burkhardt, Univ. of Connecticut at Torrington Lib.
Copyright 1991 Reed Business Information, Inc.