A Vindication of the Separate System of Prison Discipline from the Misrepresentations of the North American Review, July, 1839

Frederick Adolphus Packard

ISBN 10: 0461579200 / ISBN 13: 9780461579208

Published by HardPress, 2021

About this Item

Print on Demand.

Seller Inventory # 409092733

Bibliographic Details

• Title: A Vindication of the Separate System of Prison Discipline from the Misrepresentations of the North American Review, July, 1839
• Publisher: HardPress
• Publication Date: 2021
• Language: English
• ISBN 10: 0461579200
• ISBN 13: 9780461579208
• Binding: Soft cover
• Condition: New

About this title

Synopsis

A Vindication Of The Separate System Of Prison Discipline From The Misrepresentations Of The North American Review, July, 1839 by Frederick Adolphus Packard. This pamphlet defends the Pennsylvania separate confinement system against criticisms published in the July 1839 North American Review. Packard argues that insulation of prisoners is attainable with proper vigilance, citing reports from the Western and Eastern Penitentiaries, and rebutting witnesses such as Newcomb and Robbins as biased or misrepresented. He contrasts the Pennsylvania plan with the Auburn system, asserting that total solitude, though strict, best prevents contamination, and that keeping prisoners apart enables religious instruction and marketable trades to promote reform. The work surveys legislative reports and international authorities (Britain, France, Prussia, Belgium) who generally favor separation for moral and reformative ends. It also addresses health, cruelty, and cost, contending that abuses found in other systems are not inherent to solitary confinement. Overall, Packard argues that separate confinement is humane, practical, and superior for reform and public safety.